wall of failure


David Kelley at IDEO once said that you have to “fail faster to succeed sooner”.

You can tell a lot about an organization by how they treat failure. Do they focus on the learning or do they focus on the punishment?

When I worked at General Mills, they launched a new snack brand called Wahoos to take on Frito-Lay. The launch failed. Many who worked on the snack development project were let go.  It created something we called the Wahoos hangover. In the midst of product development, someone would invariably say, “we don’t want another Wahoos” and the team would choose to take the safest course of action.

Many companies have a form of Wahoos hangover. Successes are celebrated, but failures are turned into cautionary tales. The result is that the riskier (and potentially more breakthrough) ideas are dismissed or watered down.

David Kelley’s maxim encourages prototyping to facilitate early learning. Early failures guide the innovation process, so there is greater chance for success at launch.

My friend Kaj Johnson gave me a failed prototype from a low point in a project he helped develop. All of team’s effort had been focused on one particular project direction. Yet they couldn’t get the economics to work. So Kaj inked the letters “F-A-I-L” on the side the prototype and placed it on the table in front of the team. The act of designating the prototype as a failure allowed the team to finally let go on that particular direction and find a breakthrough in another direction altogether. There was no finger-pointing. It was just a matter-of-fact acknowledgement that failure is a part of the process. Through this failure, the team achieved greater success.

I keep the failed prototype on my desk as a reminder to celebrate and learn from failure. Failures are usually more instructive than successes.

BROWSE SIMILAR CARTOONS IN: ideations, innovation

16 Comments

  1. Mark J Owen says:

    Hi Tom,

    Excellent cartoon.

    And you are spot on about the an organisation’s perception of failure. It seems that there are lots of examples of companies that weren’t afraid to “embrace” failure.

    [Lokking forward to your next cartoon]

    - Mark
    http://markjowen.wordpress.com

  2. Mark J Owen says:

    That should be “Looking forward to…”, not “Lokking” :O)

  3. Scott says:

    What is worse, failing or not trying at all?

    -Scott.

  4. Jonathan Asher says:

    These days, the equivalent of “we don’t want another Wahoos” referred to here as a way to avoid a big failure in new products is “we don’t want to do a Tropicana” relating to an embarassing mistake when redesigning one’s packaging.

    The problem is still one of mis-applying the lesson. Many marketers take the lesson from the Tropicana fiasco to be don’t make too big too big a change, when, in fqact, the lesson should be make the right change for the situation – which Tropicana’s was not. There is still a place for a big chnage – and sometimes playing it too safe is, in fact, the riskier move for a brand’s long term success.

    Jonathan Asher
    SVP, Perception Reserach Services

  5. Tim Johnson says:

    Reminds me of the IBM legend, where Tom Watson called a VP into his office after a $5MM project failed. Watson is alleged to have asked the VP why he was there. The VP replied, “I expect to fire me.” Watson’s legendary reply was, “Why would I want to fire you? I just spent $5MM on your education.”

    We learn more from the bridges that fall down than from the ones that stay standing. If you are not failing somewhere, you’re not learning as much as you can.

  6. Misty Funk says:

    “Failures are usually more instructive than successes.” How much more true can you get? We hope for small…or inexpensive failures, right? Yet, failure can be the stimulus for something better!

  7. Sonya Duran says:

    An agency I read about had a whole wall covered in tiny tiles that read “Fail Harder”
    I thought it was a great reminder for the employees (and me, too).
    I now find myself telling my son the same thing. It’s better to try and fail, then never try at all.

    - Sonya Duran
    Ameritest

  8. graeme says:

    The opposite of failure is irrelevance

  9. Zorro says:

    You can see it all around you.

    Companies fail to take risks, and dish out one mediocre product after another.

    Sigh!

    (I’m as guilty as the rest of them)

  10. Jweb says:

    This is very true in illustration and songwriting. You’ve got to create many failures to get to the right solution. The trick, I think, is to enjoy the failures as much as the successes. More fuel for the fire. Thanks for the inspiration.

  11. [...] Wall of Failure – Tom Fishburne (cartoonist and marketer) – Nov ’10 – the positives in failure [...]

  12. [...] Many organizations are better at blamestorming than brainstorming. It is far easier to critique than to create. No one wants to end up on the wall of failure. [...]

  13. [...] and risk, words that are among the most dangerous and terrifying in business. In a blog post, Tom Fishburne, the cartoonist, summarizes a key message: You can tell a lot about an organization by how they [...]

  14. [...] and risk, words that are among the most dangerous and terrifying in business. In a blog post, Tom Fishburne, the cartoonist, summarizes a key message: You can tell a lot about an organization by how they [...]

  15. [...] and risk, words that are among the most dangerous and terrifying in business. In a blog post, Tom Fishburne, the cartoonist, summarizes a key [...]

  16. [...] Fishburne  nails fail fear with his Wall of Failure post (and cartoon).  Tom’s blog is routinely one of my go-to reads.  Here’s his post on blame-storming [...]

Leave a Comment